There must be an Engels (playing with my chart) | Letters

The authors are responding to criticism of Friedrich Engels' observations on class divisions in Manchester. They argue that the criticism attempts to downplay the significant class disparities Engels documented. The authors highlight Engels' firsthand experiences, including his companion's residence in a segregated area. They acknowledge the existence of mixed-class neighborhoods but emphasize the overwhelming presence of working-class residents, often impoverished. The authors suggest that minimizing class distinctions is an inaccurate portrayal of the historical reality. They emphasize the importance of class as a key factor in understanding the social conditions of the time. The authors counter claims that Engels exaggerated the class divide in Manchester. The writers focus on the significant economic and social differences of the historical time period. The authors are defending Engels' accurate account of social segregation. They assert the centrality of class in shaping Manchester's society.