Elon Musk claims DOGE firings will boost American manufacturing. But who will really be working in these factories?

Elon Musk advocates for shifting government employees to manufacturing jobs, a claim he's repeatedly tweeted. This theory disregards the complexities of government roles and oversimplifies labor dynamics. His assertion that all government jobs are unproductive is a gross generalization, ignoring crucial services provided. The idea that fired government workers would readily transition to manufacturing ignores the reality of skill gaps and job preferences. Many Americans don't desire factory work, and there are already more manufacturing jobs available than workers. Even if reshoring occurred, many manufacturing jobs are becoming automated. The success of reshoring itself is uncertain, with companies potentially seeking alternatives like diversification to other countries. Economic policies shift frequently, making long-term manufacturing investments risky. Ultimately, Musk's proposal is unrealistic, as automation in manufacturing renders his workforce suggestion obsolete. His plan seems more like a cynical dismissal of government workers than a viable economic strategy.