Marginal REVOLUTION Note

Marginal REVOLUTION

Marginal Revolution is an online magazine or collection of blogs that primarily deals with economics. It covers a wide variety of economic topics, with a mix of theoretical underpinnings, real-world applications, and current events. The blog is run by scholars and is affiliated with George Mason University.

Thread Of Notes

My Conversation with Dave Baszucki

Dave is CEO and co-founder of Roblox, and here is the audio, video, and transcript.  From the episode summary: With over 100 million daily active users and projected revenue bookings of $7 billion this year, it is one of the largest gaming economies in the world—and one that has made millionaires out of teenage developers […]

A Cohort Perspective on Latin America’s Fertility Transition

Latin America’s momentous fertility transition is now in the domain of history, allowing a cohort perspective on the decline of completed fertility. Using census microdata from 17 Latin American countries, we track female birth cohorts from the 1920s to the 1970s by subnational region to document the extent to which cohort fertility decline coincided with […]

Facts about American men and women

Much of what looks like changing marriage preferences over the twentieth century is actually demographics. Exploiting plausibly exogenous variation in sex ratios across U.S. birth cohorts (1870, 1930, 1950), we jointly identify preferences, match quality dynamics, and the costs of marriage and divorce. Demographics alone explain two-thirds of cross-cohort differences. Women’s premium for older husbands […]

Do teens regret their social media use?

A new study by Irish researcher Eoin Whelan attempts to answer this. Dr. Whelan told me he was specifically inspired by Haidt’s 2024 claims and sought to examine them rigorously and in the context of other regrets. This is a great use of science…testing dramatic public claims. So…do they hold up? In Dr. Whelan’s study, 389 young […]

Can Online Activity Be Regulated? Evidence from Adult Websites

The consequences of online regulations depend on the extent to which users can circumvent restrictions or substitute toward noncompliant platforms. Since 2023, 25 U.S. states have implemented age verification laws that caused prominent adult websites (including Pornhub) to restrict local access for all users. We study how these restrictions affected browsing activity using individual-level panel […]

Montana’s SB535 and a Potential Biotech Renaissance in America

In 2024, China’s NMPA approved 83 new drugs, the FDA approved 50. China’s share of new commercial clinical trials jumped from 8% globally in 2013 to 30% in 2024, just behind the US at 35%. Last year, China-based Jiangsu Hengrui Pharmaceuticals overtook AstraZeneca as the top clinical trial sponsor in the world. What’s remarkable is […]

Educational arbitrage?

Is it really all about the networking? Some people think so, and they are taking action: Justin Helman didn’t get his dream acceptance from the University of Florida. But that isn’t stopping him from pursuing the classic college experience there. The recent high-school graduate from Park Ridge, N.J., is set to move into a private apartment […]

AI nationalism, Europe included

Most of my Free Press column deals with Mythos, but here are some remarks on Europe: There is yet another huge problem behind all these first-order problems. Let us say, for instance, that France’s Mistral AI develops very nicely and serves as an EU counterpart of Anthropic and OpenAI. Well, then the other European countries […]

*Disclosure Day* (doubt if there are net spoilers in this post)

Perhaps rewatching The Omen is better prep for this movie than thinking about UFOs?  In this regard Disclosure Day is somewhat more interesting than I had been expecting. Peter Thiel, Ross Douthat, telephone! And yet I have plenty of quibbles.  It was a little too long.  The acting is entirely serviceable, but none of the […]

Germany fact of the day sentence to ponder

Champions of a European AI model should ask themselves if a European effort would be more effective than Meta, which this year will spend more on chips ($125 billion) than Germany spends on defense ($114 billion) and offer salaries of over $100 million to attract the best researchers, and is still failing to catch up. Here is […]

Republic of Ireland (China) fact of the day

Sam Enright emails me: In the most recent census (2022), 1,017,437 people in Ireland were born abroad. Even if you classify people from Taiwan as “foreigners”, there are 845,697 + 157,886 = 1,003,583 immigrants to China. There are now more foreigners in Ireland than in China in absolute terms, despite having a population that is 260 times smaller.

Who Leads? Relative Age Effects on Social Capital

A fascinating paper and result: This paper studies the causal effect of being the oldest within a school cohort on social capital. Using a fuzzy regression discontinuity design and data from Facebook, we find that boys who are older than their classmates make 11% more friends in high school. This social advantage is associated with […]

General-purpose large language models outperform specialized clinical AI tools on medical benchmarks

This result does not surprise me at all.  Here is part of the abstract: Frontier LLMs outperformed clinical AI tools in all three evaluations. Clinical AI tools performed comparably to auto-enabled Google Search AI Overview on the RCQ. These findings highlight the need for independent, real-world evaluation of AI tools before they enter clinical settings. […]

*The Pressure* (no spoilers)

A truly excellent movie, one of the best of the year.  Specifically, it concerns the meteorological forecasts (!) leading up to the D-Day invasion.  Thematically, it is about the differences between Americans and Brits, how bureaucracy operates, the nature of leadership, and the proper role of science in government.  It is like an old-style Hollywood […]

The Cultural War is a Civil War

Kevin Bryan riffs on on my post The Nationalization of American Science. He is rightfully incensed: AT is right this is a red tape-filled science policy of “losers”. If you think “cut funds from DEI-driven professors in the small departments no one cares about” is more important than “make sure the world’s strongest fundamental science […]

The bullish case for Brazil

From Drew Crawford: Start with the most important number in economics, even though no one on Wall Street talks about it: calories per acre. Human civilization runs on food. Ten billion people will inhabit this planet by 2050. The amount of arable land is not growing. It is shrinking, every year, to urbanization, desertification, salinization, […]

Sometimes it is hard to solve for the equilibrium

Probably you all know about this: The US government, citing national security authorities, has issued an export control directive to suspend all access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5 by any foreign national, whether inside or outside the United States, including foreign national Anthropic employees. The net effect of this order is that we must […]

How did Stanislaw Lem imagine advanced computer intelligence?

…GOLEM’s behavior is unpredictable.  Sometimes it converses courteously with people, whereas on other occasions any attempt at contact misfires.  GOLEM sometimes cracks jokes, too, though its sense of humor is fundamentally different from man’s.  Much depends on its interlocutors.  In exceptional casese GOLEM will show a certain interest in people who are talented in a […]

Safety and nation-building in Mexico

That is the topic of my latest Free Press column, here is one excerpt: Consider the special nature of Mexican politics. First and foremost, Mexico is still not a mature nation-state. By one estimate, drug gangs may control as much as one-third of its territory. That might sound bizarre, but from the standpoint of Mexican history, […]

Friday assorted links

1. Is there too much free parking in NYC? (NYT) 2. New Malcolm Gladwell book forthcoming on violence in America.  Ready for pre-order. 3. Manufacturing requirements are killing gene and cell therapy. 4. “Long-term exposure to urban air pollution damages the heart even at the relatively low levels found in many developed countries, a cardiac […]

Here Comes the Sun(screen)

I have been banging on about FDA delay in approving new sunscreens since 2013. Well it has finally happened. Twenty six years after being approved by the European Union and thirteen years after then-FDA Commissioner Margaret A. Hamburg told lawmakers that sorting out the sunscreen issue was “one of the highest priorities” the FDA has […]

Again, the research paper format will be dying out

From Xudong Han: ‘Recently, I came across a paper co-authored by 37 authors from Stanford, CMU, Michigan, and elsewhere: *The Last Human-Written Paper*. The core argument is pretty brutal: the paper format we’ve been using for centuries might already be obsolete in the AI era. The authors point out two “invisible taxes” that we’ve long […]

Orwell on Dickens and progress

What is more striking, in a seemingly ‘progressive’ radical, is that he is not mechanically minded. He shows no interest either in the details of machinery or in the things machinery can do. As Gissing remarks, Dickens nowhere describes a railway journey with anything like the enthusiasm he shows in describing journeys by stage-coach. In […]

A simple reason for skepticism about the iPhones/fertility link

Here is the background to the debate.  Here is more from Noah.  Here is a thread from researcher Caitlin Myers.  And here is some basic information: In 2008, 1.9% is the share of the mobile-subscribing population with an iPhone wireless subscription.  As a percent of all adults that is 1.6%. In 2009, it is 4.3%.  […]

Thursday assorted links

1. Fable 5 describes humanity.  And Anthropic policy proposals, including for economics. 2. “Can you build a working chess board which then illustrates and can play the moves of the famous “Evergreen game”?”  The response.  Much better yet is Fable 5 explaining Riemann. 3. Marcus Nunes on Chile vs. Argentina. 4. In the video world, […]

The Nationalization of American Science

OMB, joined by some forty grantmaking agencies—NSF, HHS, DOE, NASA, DOD among them—has proposed a sweeping rewrite of the rules governing all federal grants, the Regulation for Federal Financial Assistance. American science has long been state funded but not state directed. Since Vannevar Bush, money has flowed through many agencies to independent universities, allocated largely […]

My excellent Conversation with Katja Hoyer

Here is the audio, video, and transcript.  Here is part of the episode summary: Tyler and Katja discuss why communism made East Germans more loyal to the system while it bred dissidents in Poland and Hungary, how happy or unhappy life in the GDR actually was, Tyler’s own bleak day-trip to East Berlin in 1984, […]

What do the AIs think of us?

Asked to answer as a typical human, every cutting-edge model rated us markedly more neurotic, less open, less agreeable and less conscientious than they rated themselves. The gap on Neuroticism alone is 1.69 points on a 5-point scale. Here is more material of interest.  And this: Across 31 models from those seven labs they answer […]

Wednesday assorted links

1. New edition of Copernicus on money. 2. Denazification of the United States?  Denazification actually consisted of: “…dissolution of Nazi organizations, licensing/control of new political organizations, individual classification by denazification tribunals, and temporary or permanent disabilities on voting, standing for office, party membership, officeholding, public speech professions, and public/private employment.” 3. Faster replies increase your […]

Stanislaw Lem foresaw drones

This was published in English (and Polish) in 1986 under the title One Human Minute: So it was not humanoid automata that former the new armies but synthetic insects (synsects) — ceramic microcrustacea, titanium annelids, and flying pseudo-hymenoptera with nerve centers made of arsenic compounds and with stingers of heavy, fissionable elements…The flying synsect combined […]

How well does current AI find errors in economics papers?

Can artificial intelligence (AI) refute economic theory? I document experiments in which I asked several AI models (Gemini, Refine, Claude, and ChatGPT) to check the correctness of four published papers in economic theory, each containing an error that I helped identify or correct. ChatGPT Pro performed best, occasionally constructing counterexamples and corrected proofs, while other […]

Hayekian Literary Criticism

In economics, Marx is relegated to the history of thought as his ideas were an economic dead end and a political disaster. Yet Marx-influenced literary criticism is a dominant mode of analysis in nearly every English department in the country. It’s not that the English professors are all Marxists, it’s that even the non-Marxists reach […]

New paper on the iPhone and fertility

The U.S. general fertility rate has fallen by 22% since 2007, a sustained decline not readily explained by economic conditions, contraceptive use, housing or childcare costs, or other commonly cited factors. We assess the potential role of a different shock: the diffusion of the smartphone. The U.S. rollout of the iPhone, the first modern smartphone, […]

Might AI hurt corporate profits? (from my email)

From Clifford Sosin: I loved your talk about AI and wanted to bounce an idea off you. I think AI may be bad for corporate profit margins. A lot of companies make money because their customers can’t be bothered to monitor them more closely, or to insource something. Customers let the company make some money […]