Axios
Follow
Florida shouldn't have been ordered to dismantle Alligator Alcatraz, appeals court finds
An appellate panel has overturned a federal judge's order to dismantle Florida's Alligator Alcatraz immigration facility. This ruling temporarily halts the previous injunction that stopped new detainees from being sent to the site. The decision is a win for Governor Ron DeSantis and President Trump, who supported the facility. Environmental groups and the Miccosukee Tribe had sued, claiming the facility's construction violated the National Environmental Policy Act. A federal judge agreed, stating the state failed to evaluate the environmental impact on the Everglades. Florida appealed this ruling to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. The state argued the facility had no environmental impact as it was built on an old airstrip. Environmental groups, however, cited new construction and expert testimony about risks to the surrounding ecosystem. The appeals court found the lower judge was wrong to believe the environmentalists would likely win their case. They also suggested the judge exceeded her authority by ordering dismantling instead of halting construction. Governor DeSantis expressed his commitment to keeping the facility operational. Environmental groups expressed disappointment but vowed to continue their fight, hoping for success in the full appeal. The core of the lawsuit centered on the state's alleged failure to conduct required environmental studies. The appeals court, however, referenced a Supreme Court ruling that narrowed the scope of the environmental review law. They also disagreed that the facility's construction constituted "major federal action" requiring such review. This latest ruling only pauses the previous decision while the government's appeal proceeds.