The article discusses serious failings surrounding academic Jason Arday's promotion at the University of Cambridge. Colleagues are rightly calling for an independent investigation into his appointment and the subsequent controversies. Allegations of plagiarism and questionable claims about his background and charity work are still being examined. His upcoming memoir, which reportedly details his triumphs over adversity including an autism diagnosis, is also under scrutiny. The university’s failure to conduct thorough due diligence before Arday's highly publicised appointment is highlighted. Furthermore, Cambridge's insufficient response to the challenges that arose has caused significant harm. This situation has negatively impacted efforts to increase the representation of black and neurodivergent scholars in esteemed academic roles. It also undermines the work of those who have strived to promote underrepresented groups in prominent positions. The publisher of Arday's memoir should consider pausing its release pending the outcome of the inquiries. Ultimately, these individual failings should not detract from broader progressive objectives.