This Radiolab episode from 2019 explores the unexpected story of hockey player John Scott. Scott, known for his toughness and brawling on the ice, became the target of a fan-driven prank. A pundit initiated a campaign for fans to vote Scott into the NHL All-Star Game. This online campaign unexpectedly succeeded, thrusting Scott into a complex situation. He was now set to play alongside the league's elite players. The episode examines whether this was a dream come true or a cruel joke. The story delves into the internet's influence and the implications of online democracy. It explores the agony and ecstasy Scott experienced during this period. The episode uses Scott's story to discuss broader themes. The provided text offers links to Scott's podcast and book, along with Radiolab's credits.